Shomer Negiah: Why Not Touching Before Marriage Is Less Crazy Than You Thought

Several years ago, I was at a conference, and a guy at my table started up with me after he found out that I was observant. “I’m not religious,” he began, “but I get Shabbat. I see the value in kosher. But that whole no touching before marriage thing that you Orthodox Jews do – that is NUTS.” He was referring to “shomer negiah,” the prohibition in Jewish law of touching a member of the opposite sex outside of your nuclear family – including boyfriends and girlfriends.

Truth be told, growing up as a secular Jew, I had no clue that this law was even part of my religion. I remember, as a kid, watching a show on TV about religious Christians who didn’t touch before marriage and clearly thinking they were out of their minds. I was a late bloomer (read nerd) in high school, so as I started becoming more observant, it wasn’t like shomer negia was going to crimp my style, but still, it wasn’t the first mitzvah that I ran to adopt on my road to Orthodoxy.

Then on a date, during my senior year of high school, an older guy tried to take advantage of me. (Thankfully, I was able to get away before he did.) Suddenly shomer negia, which I had first heard about the summer beforeseemed like a very good idea. After I started keeping it, though, I became more committed to a Jewish observant lifestyle in general and continued to keep it out of conviction. Having only adopted this mitzvah at seventeen and then getting married to the first real guy I dated at twenty meant that I did not have to “suffer” through the challenge of negia for too long, so I won’t pretend to know what that is like, nor will I pretend that it is easy, and I certainly won’t judge anyone who has struggled in this very difficult mitzvah.

All that being said, I think it is a brilliant practice, and here’s what I told that guy who told me that it is nuts: In the rest of the world, being single means being “free.” Why? Because singles can acquire as many sexual escapades as they want, or at least as many they can get. Then suddenly marriage comes along, and both parties are in a “prison” of sorts for the rest of their lives. (Or at least for the rest of their marriage.) How do I know this is true? Well, what is a wife called? “The old ball and chain.” Think about the ramifications of that for a moment.

See, in the Orthodox world, we do it backwards. We start people off in “prison.” We make them suffer in singlehood and make them feel motivated to get married. (It should be noted that desiring to be married and finding a suitable mate, unfortunately, are not always synonymous.) Then, in married life, the couple suddenly attains a new freedom which they never had access to before. But just so they don’t get too used to this “freedom” and stop appreciating it, every month, the couple is back on “lock down,” i.e. niddah (the two week physical separation which proceeds a dunk in the mikvah) so that touch can always remaining something exciting.

By the time I was done with my explanation, it was very clear that the conference attendee didn’t think I was so nuts any more…

 NOTE: Some people think you need to “test” someone out before you marry him or her. Jewish law says you have to be attracted to your spouse before you get married, teaches that the essence of love “ahava” occurs through “giving” (the root of “ahava” is “havey” which means “give” in Aramaic), and requires a husband to sexually satisfy his wife as part of her marriage contract. Of course there are people who do not get properly prepared before the wedding, nor do they make enough effort to work on this after the wedding, but this is what the goal is meant to be.

If you found this content meaningful and want to help further our mission through our Keter, Makom, and Tikun branches, please consider becoming a Change Maker today.


1 comment

Sort by

  • Avatar photo Just Assume That Everyone Around You Is Shomer Negiah - Jew in the City says on April 4, 2019

    […] Shomer negiah is a concept in Judaism which means that people don’t touch others of the opposite sex outside of their nuclear family. It is based on the Torah source “lo tikravu galos erva” which that a man should not even approach the “ervah” or “nakedness” of a woman who is not his wife (or even his own wife when she is in a state of niddah). The idea of this prohibition is that there are many steps along the way that can lead to sex, and according to traditional Jewish thought, we stop before we get to any of them, lest we descend down the proverbial slippery slope. […]


Contact formLeave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related posts

Noa Argamani’s Redemption Gives Us A Model To Dream Of

The Truth on How Israelis are Fighting this War (Despite What the Media Says)

Previous post

The Hasidic Jew Who Went Viral on YouTube High-Fiving New Yorkers

Next post

How Can The Torah Let A Man Sell His Daughter into Slavery?

We’ll Schlep To You

In Your
Inbox Weekly