To the OTD Community: I’m Sorry I Didn’t Understand Your Pain

When one person hurts another, even if she did so unintentionally, she should still apologize. That’s why I’ve decided to write this post. Because I didn’t understand the pain that some people who grew up Orthodox experienced until pretty recently, and not understanding made me not sensitive enough. During my proud secular Jewish childhood, I was raised to hate the Orthodox community. We only knew them from afar, but they were “extreme,” “closed-minded,” “uneducated,” and “backwards.” They had nothing to do with us.

Then, at 16 years old, after being launched into an existential crisis at age eight due to a father of children in my school who murdered them, then killed himself, I accidentally met an Orthodox Jew up close, and for the first time since that awful tragedy occurred, I was full of hope that life might not be completely pointless. The guy was nice. He was normal. Not only was his life not horribly restricted, he had something that I was missing — meaning. I felt betrayed that I was not given this information despite having been privileged to receive an otherwise excellent education.

After discovering the riches contained within a religious Jewish life, I slowly made a journey to observance to follow in the footsteps of my forefathers, but my family thought I had lost my mind. I challenged them to base their opinions on knowledge, not stereotypes and, one by one, as they began to learn, each of them saw the beauty of Torah and mitzvos and joined me. This phenomenon was the catalyst for starting an organization – Jew in the City. If I felt shortchanged by not having had a chance to see observance correctly, it seemed only right that every Jew should get to know of the beauty that is possible in a life of Torah and mitzvos.

While I ultimately landed in the right-wing side of the modern Orthodox world, I have spent considerable time with Orthodox Jews from every community and have many close friends and relatives from these places. Our goal at Jew in the City has always been to be “big tent” about Orthodoxy. To show the beauty contained in every branch. I went to a seminary called Darche Noam which stresses that there are numerous valid paths to observance and that each Jew should find his or her own. Some communities emphasize chesed (acts of kindness), others emphasize a commitment to Torah study, others stress tolerance, while others accentuate faith.

I never saw ugliness in the Orthodox Jewish community, up close. I never saw the judgments or the boxes so small that human beings can’t fit into them. I never saw cheating or fear-based education. Or cover ups. I saw beauty, so I told Orthodoxy as I knew it.

But the people who experienced the ugliness — who only experienced the ugliness — came to our platforms and called me a liar. I didn’t understand. There were several years of contentious social media threads. Me describing Orthodoxy honestly (from my perspective), them accusing me of whitewashing. While I understand that these people came to our platforms with frustration and feelings of betrayal of my simply not getting their reality, unfortunately, a conversation based on vitriol does not lead to a dialogue.

Then, a few years ago, some of the people who experienced the ugliness took a different approach. Instead of calling me a liar, they approached me in a respectful manner. They believed that what we describe on Jew in the City is true and they wanted it for themselves. A sincere and growth-oriented one that is integrated with the world, but careful about halacha. That contains room for self while developing a connection to the Almighty. Because this conversation began assuming that I did not purposely mislead, a real conversation could begin and I started to learn up close about the horrors they had lived through.

That was the impetus for starting Makom. Not to “make OTD religious again” and not to “make happy charedim modern Orthodox.” We built Makom to help interested Jews who had been raised with a dysfunctional Orthodox Judaism find a healthy and happy one. Not every person who comes to Makom wants to leave the charedi world. Some simply want to connect with healthy members of the charedi world — the amazing ones that I have been privileged to know.

So back to my apology — to the people who grew up experiencing Judaism as a weapon – I’m sorry that I didn’t understand what you went through. I simply didn’t know it was happening. Hearing the stories of the members of Makom over these last couple years, I understand it more now than ever. It’s not supposed to be this way, and I’m sorry that it was. I’m sorry if our rosy depiction of Orthodoxy made your experience seem invalid. It is not. We did not intentionally gloss over problems. They are just so far from how we’ve experienced Orthodoxy.

The point of Jew in the City was never to worry about image instead of goodness. It was to publicize actual goodness. We can only be a kiddush Hashem when our actions ARE a kiddush Hashem. There is MUCH kiddush Hashem in the Orthodox world and so much I am proud of and feel blessed every day to be part of. But there are problems which need to be fixed and the chillul Hashem will not go away until the root of the problems are corrected.  Our mission ten years after our founding is the same as it was the day we began: every Jew should know that there is beauty and meaning in Torah and mitzvos. And anyone who is interested in partaking of that beauty should have the chance to do so.

If you found this content meaningful and want to help further our mission through our Keter, Makom, and Tikun branches, please consider becoming a Change Maker today.



Sort by

  • Avatar photo David Cheifetz says on December 7, 2017

    Allison Josephs – Thank for such a lovely, deeply honest, and thought provoking piece.

    I was raised Yeshivish and migrated to Modern Orthodox, and while I joke with my friends about some of the dysfunction I experienced, I too never saw the dark side until I began to spend close time with OTD-era, many who are ex-Chassidim in various phases or existential struggle.

    Well, what I said was not entirely true. I did see the dark side – I was sexually abused at the age of 13 by a 28 year old Rabbi, and was subsequently the victim of a cover up by the camp where the abuse took place. But I never – consciously at least – associated that experience with the broader Orthodox Community.

    Until I became friendswith my Chareidistan raised friends and learned of forced arranged marriages, physical abuse, communities hanging together to steal the children of a spouse who is no longer observant, a lack of secular education leading to a cycle of poverty, Community Morality Squads, and kids being kicked to the street from their homes for crimes like going to the library. Oh, and lots of sexual abuse. “Rampant” might be a descriptive term.

    But while my theology and philosophy have evolved, I have continued to see value input tradition, our nation, our culture.

    So I write with great respect to thank you for your honesty at acknowledging that the world is not black and white. and certainly not the Orthodox world. Sadly, too many people have focused on Mitzvot Bain Adam LaMakom – Commandmengs related to man’s relationship with God, such as prayer and the size of one’s Yarmulke, and have disregarded Mitzvot Bain Adam LeChaveiro, basic decency in interactions with other human beings.

    It takes a lot to acknowledge and apologize. Cudos to you.

  • Avatar photo A.T. says on December 8, 2017

    What exactly are you apologizing for? You have nothing to apologize for. I came from almost the exact background as you, and became a Bal Yeshivah at Our Somayach in Jerusalem. Should I apologise that I had awesome Rabbeim – teachers, that taught Torah the way it was supposed to be taught, and showed me the beauty of living a Torah True lifestyle?
    The Rabbis and teachers of these unfortunate OTD Jews are the ones that need to apologize to them for giving them a bad education. Thier parents need to apologize to them for not showing them the beauty of Torah and Mitzvahs.
    Mainly the OTD Jews I meet are the result of a couple factors….a bad Torah education, and/or bad parenting. When it’s bad parenting, it’s usually parents that did not teach thier children any coping skills, or how to take responsibility for thier actions, and how to be an adult.
    Is this answer over simplified? Yes, but I’m typing this on my phone, and this is not exactly the best forum for this discussion. To sum it up, you don’t owe anyone an apology. You, and many Bal Teshuvas are owed a debt of gratitude for showing the world the beauty and appreciation of a Torah True lifestyle, and how people should be willing to change thier entire life, and way they were raised to come to a life of Torah and Mitzvahs.

    • Avatar photo Allison Josephs says on December 13, 2017

      Thanks for your comment, A.T. Of course the people who hurt them should apologize. But being a sensitive person is part of being a good person. I’m proud that we show the world the beauty of Torah and mitzvos. But these people were raised keeping Torah and mitzvos and these things that should be so beautiful were used as weapons against them. I didn’t have that insight until recently – how much someone can suffer in the Orthodox world. And only saying the good does not acknowledge the very real problems they went through and that people are still going through. I wouldn’t want anyone to think I was purposely whitewashing. I have always described Orthodoxy as I’ve experienced it but their experiences count too and frankly these issues need to be fixed.

    • Avatar photo Arby says on March 1, 2018

      I somehow came across this article and the acronym OTD caught my eye. I have no issues with what the author wrote. I thought it was very thoughtful and open-minded. This is more in response to the previous poster A.T.

      Both my parents came from secular backgrounds before “finding” religion, meeting each other and then raising a family. I grew up in a very Ultra-Orthodox home (not chassidic) with strict rules, very little secular education and the mighty fear of hell. So why did OTD stand out to me? Because I am what you consider OTD. And no, no one did wrong by me. Did I receive a bad education? Yes. But that is NOT why I decided to choose another path in life. People (like you) come up with these excuses for why someone like me may not agree or choose the lifestyle you choose. It seems you are not comfortable accepting the idea that Religion is a personal choice that may not work for everyone, so you need to find a reason or a person to blame. Rabbis, parents, neighbors….whatever. With the finger pointing and blame being passed around for the “injustice” you think happened, you are forgetting one person. You are forgetting ME. By doing that you are implying that I am not smart enough, or enough of an adult to make my own CORRECT choices. Or that something bad must have happened for me to choose this “terrible” life. I am an intelligent person and I take offense to that implication. I am perfectly capable of taking responsibility for my actions; a privilege you have not granted me. I chose this life because I chose happiness. This is my happiness. Yours may be different and I respect that; just as I respect my family and everyone else for whatever life path they chose to take as long as the decision was based on what you felt was right for you. – Traditional, Ultra-Orthodox, Modern Orthodox, Secular, Christianity, Buddhism…etc. It’s insulting that the choices I made using my intellectual abilities are being taken away from me simply because you do not agree with it. As for my parents- they have nothing to apologize for. My parents are the most incredible people I know and by far some of the smartest too. So don’t put this on them. They may not have wanted this for me because they too feel that Yiddishkeit is the only correct path, but ultimately I was raised to use my brain and I did. Again, I chose my life. I love my life. I wouldn’t change it for the world. Hold me responsible for my choices and honor my ability to choose what works for me. The paths we take and the decisions we make in life define us so don’t erase me from my life’s journey.


Contact formLeave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related posts

How To Debate An Anti-Zionist In 5 Easy Steps

An Open Letter to the Social Justice Warriors Who Unapologetically Support Terrorism

Previous post

Is There a Jewish Response on How Not to Get Corrupted By Power?

Next post

The Frum "Friends" Wraps its First Season & Other Orthodox Jews in the News

We’ll Schlep To You

In Your
Inbox Weekly